Revisiting the Smith & Wesson Model 10 and the Colt Official Police
For the past two decades police departments across the country have been relying on nothing but semi-automatic pistols made by Glock, Smith & Wesson, Sturm Ruger and Beretta, but for well over seventy years law enforcement officers carried .38 Special revolvers that came from the two biggest gun makers of the day, the Smith & Wesson Model 10, and the Colt Official Police.
The Smith & Wesson Model 10
The Smith & Wesson Model 10 started life as the Military and Police Revolver of 1899, and was also known as the Hand Ejector First Model. With the introduction of this gun Smith & Wesson also gave the world the .38 Special1, which was destined to become the standard cartridge against which all other police rounds were measured. The First Model was lacking a barrel under lug that was to be a facet on later models that held the front locking lug in place. In addition to .38 Special, the First Model also came in .32-20, and .38 Long Colt and had a set of fixed sights.
Three years later Smith & Wesson brought out the Second Model Hand Ejector, more commonly known as the Model 1902 Military & Police Second Model which now had the barrel under lug and used two pins inserted in the hammer sides to prevent them from rubbing on the inside of the action.
In another three years Smith & Wesson came up with the Military & Police Model 1905 which was to become the predecessor of the M&P revolvers available today. The Third Model has the reciprocating cylinder stop and a coil spring and plunger which differed from the leaf spring of the earlier models.
There were some other minor changes over the years, but the 1905 M&P was the gun that made its way into the holsters of a great number of police officers. Barrel lengths were four, five and six-inches to start, and a two-inch barrel was added in 1933. The sights offered were still the fixed blade and groove rear.
The Military & Police (Smith & Wesson didn’t begin calling the M&P the Model 10 until 1958 when they began numbering their model) weighs in at 30 ounces with a four-inch barrel. During World War II Smith & Wesson began making the Victory Model M&P with a parkerized finish and a lanyard swivel. The American Victory had a four-inch barrel and was chambered in .38 Special while the British version, known as the K-2002, was chambered in .38 S&W (.38-200) and came in four, five and six-inch barrel lengths.
The barrels on the Model 10 from inception were tapered with a large rounded fixed front sight and a groove for the rear until 1961 when a heavy barrel was added to the line with a ramped front sight. Both versions were commonly used by police departments well into the 1990s with little modifications. Some departments (like the New York State Department of Corrections) still use Model 10s as their primary duty weapon. The grips were originally made of wood, but the current Model 10 can be ordered with rubber grips as well. The Model 10 manufactured by Smith & Wesson today is nearly the same gun that was being produced one hundred years ago.
The Colt Official Police
The genesis for the Colt double action revolver began with the Colt 1889 or the New Army & Navy chambered in .38 Long Colt. When Smith & Wesson brought out their Military & Police revolver ten years later their .38 Special provided much better performance than the .38 Long Colt. With their main competition now making a better and more powerful gun, Colt was forced to play catch up.
In 1908 Colt began making their Police Positive revolver chambered in the .38 Colt Special, which was nothing more than the .38 Smith & Wesson Special with a different head stamp. That same year Colt also introduced the New Army revolver, a bigger and heavier redesign of the New Army & Navy. Changes included a rounded checkered cylinder latch, a wider rear sight groove, a matted top strap and a checkered trigger. Barrel lengths were four, five and six-inch in either blued or a nickel finish. In 1927 Colt renamed the New Army & Navy the Official Police revolver in an attempt to boost law enforcement sales.
The Official Police revolver became a big hit with many police agencies and was adopted by the FBI. Colt also made a parkerized version during World War II known as the Commando, in either a two or a four-inch barrel. After the war ended Colt began its rivalry anew Smith & Wesson over law enforcement sales. In the 1960s Smith & Wesson’s Model 10 was outselling the Official Police revolver and in 1969 Colt dropped the gun. In 1970 Colt began making a cheaper version of the Official Police but sales were dismal and production was stopped in 1973.
On the range
I thought that there could be no better (subjective) comparison than to actually use a pair of “retired” police guns. The Model 10 that I acquired was a vintage NYPD heavy barreled version from 1963. The NYPD had been using Model 10 and Colt revolvers since the department adopted the .38 Special cartridge in May of 1926.
The NYPD Model 10 was in nearly pristine condition for a retired service weapon, and although it had a set of aftermarket rubber grips, those were replaced with a set of the original wood stocks. Using standard .38 Special loads since the gun was not rated for +P ammunition, I decided to shoot the Model 10 from what would be qualification ranges, so neither the Smith nor the Colt was bench rested.
It should be mentioned here just how police departments in the old days had their firearms qualifications. Until the 1950s and the 1960s, officers did not fire their revolvers double action. This was one of the things that affected the sales at Colt and why Smith & Wesson began to dominate the market3.
I first fired a cylinder full of Winchester 125-grain jacketed soft points off-hand at 15 yards single action, and then followed up with another six rounds of the same, but double action. I finished up by firing six rounds of Remington 158-grain lead bullets at 10 yards and six of the Winchester and six of the Remington rounds into an IDPA pistol target at seven yards, all shot double action.
The Model 10 proved to be fairly accurate, despite the fact that the wooden stocks did not fit my hand well at all. The Smith proved to be well balanced, and I can see why it has served as a duty gun for such a long time.
The other half of the test was a Colt Official Police revolver that was also retired from the New York City Police Department. There was a small inlay of a badge and number in the right grip from the MOS who once carried the Colt “on the job.” Like the Model 10, the Colt had a four-inch barrel and was made in 1956. The rear sight channel on the Colt is a bit longer but appears to be the same width and depth. Sizing the two guns up, the Official Police is a bit lighter, and seems to be balanced a little better than the Model 10, and I have always preferred Colt’s cylinder release to that of the Smith & Wesson, but that is just a personal preference.
I tested the Colt out at the same ranges as the Smith, with the same ammunition. While the Colt fit my hand better, it had a much longer double action trigger pull.
Overall both revolvers shot very well for being fixed sight duty guns, but the Colt proved to be more accurate. The Model 10 seemed to be heavier on the barrel end, and those wooden stocks made consistent shooting nearly impossible with their poor fit. The Smith & Wesson did have its strong points however with its better trigger pull, both single and double action. I’m confident that with aftermarket grips, in my hand the Model 10 would be just as accurate as the Colt, but I wanted to test both guns in their original “as issued” guise.
Each of these revolvers affirmed why they were such great duty guns. Both the Model 10 and the Official Police certainly were adequate then and now for “stopping the bad guy.”
Untold sworn officers walked their beats or rode their sectors carrying either a Smith & Wesson or a Colt over the decades. None lacked for protection with either strapped to his hip. Even in this day of modern high capacity pistols one could do worse than to have the Model 10 or the Official Police in their duty holster.