The Best 9mm Handgun Ever Made

Last Updated on

The overwhelming preference in the current handgun market is for weapons in the 9mm caliber. The reasons for this include high velocity, compact size and high magazine capacity. This is a direct outgrowth of the adoption of the 9mm for duty weapons by military and law enforcement worldwide.

Because of the huge market and large number of available models, this can be great news for anyone shopping for a personal defense weapon.

With all this competition and wide variety, choices abound in style, size and price. Here’s a look at some of the candidates for the best 9mm handgun ever made. If you want to view some of great 9mm’s check out the complete handgun guide here.

Best 9mm Handgun Ever Made – Top 5

Springfield XDm9


XDM9 Reviews

  • Highest Capacity (19 round magazine)
  • Comfortable to shoot W/ minimal kick
  • Aggressive styling
  • Holster and magazine Pouch included
  • Easy to disassemble and maintain


  • Slightly heavy (32 ounces)
  • Not made in USA

The Springfield Armory XDm 9mm pistol is ranked #1 because it is a reliable and comfortable gun that is loaded with features and accessories. The second you take hold of the XDm you will notice how well the grip is designed and how comfortable it is to hold in your hands. Shooting the XDM is very comfortable because the kick from recoil can barely be felt and the sights line up naturally. The trigger is very nice and it breaks consistently at around 6 pounds of pressure.

The Springfield Armory XDm handgun is shipped to you in a durable hard case that includes the handgun, two 19 magazines, a right handed holster, a magazine pouch, and adjustable grip inserts. The adjustable grip inserts allow for shooters with all hand sizes to enjoy shooting the pistol. The grip and slide are textured in a way that makes gripping and handling the XDm very simple. The XDm magazine holds 19 round of 9mm and a round can be kept safely in the chamber.

The Springfield Armory XDm 9mm Pistol has a polymer frame and a stainless steel slide that is coated black. This handgun is very rugged and will function flawlessly in harsh environments. It has excellent sights. The XDm features an external grip safety. There is a small slide lock release lever and a takedown lever on the side of the XDm. There is also an accessory rail for mounting lights and lasers.

The Springfield Armory XDm 9mm handgun is simple to disassemble and clean. It is almost as easy to take apart as the Glock. The XDm design has been around for a very long time because it is the pistol used by law enforcement in Croatia, so the design is time tested and proven. The XDm can be counted on as being very reliable.

There is no question that the Springfield Armory XDm Pistol has style. It is a great gun to look at which means there are many proud XDm owners out there. Although this trait has nothing to do with how the gun functions, the way the handgun looks can be important to handgun owners.

The Springfield Armory XDm pistol is heavier than the Glock 17 Gen-4 or the Smith & Wesson M&P. However the added features and accessories make it a tremendous value.

#2 Glock 17 Gen 4


Glock 9mm Reviews

  • High Capacity (17 round magazine)
  • Light Weight (22 ounces)
  • Comfortable to shoot with minimal kick
  • Extreme durability and reliability
  • Simple to take apart and clean
  • Endless aftermarket accessories


  • Lesser quality sights
  • Less features than XDm

The Glock Model 17 Gen-4 9mm pistol is ranked number #2 due to its time-tested simplicity, durability and reliability.  The Glock is the most popular 9mm pistol in the world.  The firing mechanism is simple and contains a minimal amount of parts.  The Polymer frame and stainless steel coated slide is extremely rugged and weather resistant.  The Glock has a reputation for being the most reliable semi automatic handgun ever built.   It is no wonder the Glock is the most common pistol used by police officers.

The Glock Model 17 Gen-4 is a comfortable gun to shoot.  Its full sized polymer frame greatly reduces the amount of kick felt by the shooter.  The trigger breaks cleanly at around 8 pounds and resets with a nice audible and tactical click.  There is no external safety lever.  There is a small slide lock release lever.  There is an accessory rail for mounting lights and lasers.  The magazine holds 17 rounds of potent 9mm ammo and a round can be kept safely in the chamber.

This Model 17 Generation 4 has new features which cannot be found on previous generation Glocks.  The grip can be adjusted for a variety of hands by using the included grip inserts.  A textured gripping surface called polymids is built into the polymer frame providing a more secure grip.  Also, there are three 17 round magazines and a magazine loading tool included with the gun shipped to you in a stylish hard case.

The Glock Model 17 Gen-4 is very easy to disassemble and reassemble without tools.  It is easier to clean than most other guns and requires minimal lubrication.    There is a tremendous amount of aftermarket accessories available for the Glock, offering affordable customization options.

The Glock 17 is provided with plastic sights which function fine.  However the sights are not of the same quality as provided on the Smith & Wesson M&P or the Springfield Armory XDm.  Even though the sites on the GLock are not the best, there are many sights available on the internet if you wish to upgrade them.  The Glock may be blocky and utilitarian in design but its ruggedness and reliability are unmatched.    Buy a Glock Model 17 Gen-4 today at a price of $549.99 shipped free to your local Federal Firearms License Holder (FFL).

#3 Smith & Wesson MP9


MP9 Reviews

  • High Capacity (17 round Magazine)
  • Light Weight (24 ounces)
  • Comfortable to shoot with low kick
  • High Quality Sights
  • Made in USA


  • More difficult to take apart for cleaning
  • New to the market place

The Smith & Wesson M&P 9mm pistol is ranked number #3 because of how comfortable the gun is to hold in your hand.  The ergonomics of the M&P 9mm are excellent.  You will also find it very comfortable to shoot, as its size and shape greatly reduce the kick felt by the shooter.  Another feature that makes the M&P 9mm enjoyable to shoot is the excellent trigger.  The trigger breaks cleanly at around 6 pounds.  The M&P comes with two magazines that hold 17 rounds of 9mm ammo, plus a round can be kept safely in the chamber.

The Smith & Wesson M&P 9mm handgun has a Polymer frame and a stainless steel slide.  The stainless Steel slide is coated black to match the black polymer frame.  The front of the M&P pistol includes an accessory rail so that flashlights or lasers sights can be easily mounted.  The sights are excellent quality and are very easy to see.

The controls on the Smith & Wesson M&P 9mm handgun are simple to use. There is a thumb safety for right handed shooters.  The grip of the Smith & Wesson M&P 9mm pistol is adjustable to accommodate shooters with large, medium and small hands.  It takes just a few moments to swap out the different sized grip inserts which Smith and Wesson includes along with the gun in a nice hard case.

The Smith and Wesson M&P is a bit more complicated to disassemble than the Glock 17 and the Springfield Armory XDM.  We also noticed that the M&P is a more complicated design from an engineering standpoint because it is made up of more internal parts.  Also, the Smith & Wesson M&P 9mm is a relative newcomer to the market place, so it does not have the same track record as the Glock 17 or the Springfield Armory XDm.

1. Sig Sauer P290 (Discontinued)

The P290 is Sig’s entry in the rapidly expanding market for medium-bore compact guns intended for concealed carry. This is a small pistol with a polymer frame and stainless steel slide. It has more heft and weight than similar handguns by other makers, and with such a small gun, the weight helps to make it more controllable when firing the hotter +P rounds it is rated for.

It is a very balanced design, allowing it to point well and stay on target as well as any gun this small can do. There have been some complaints by owners on magazine fit and feed reliability.

Sig offers a small laser that can be mounted in an integral fashion forward of the trigger guard. One interesting option is the ability to replace the side plates on the grip with others of different material such as rubber or wood. It’s important to note that this gun is not legal for sale in either Massachusetts or California.

2. Springfield XD

Springfield’s XD is probably the king of sales in the small carry gun category. The XD line consists of everything from full-sized duty weapons down to the shortest compact carry pistol available.

Compared to the Sig Sauer P290 it is far easier to break down and owners love the gun. It comes with a choice of night sights or plain black ones and they can be replaced with aftermarket offerings. The XD also includes a rail for mounting optics, even on the little 3-inch sub compact gun.

The XD resembles the Glock in overall look, feel and construction, but the geometry differs slightly and many Glock users find that they prefer this difference in the Springfield. Like the Glock, the Springfield XD has a polymer frame and metal slide, and it has developed a reputation for flawless feeding.

These are well-built and substantial guns, but are lighter than the P290 in the sub compact size. This can mean more muzzle rise and more difficulty keeping the gun on target. Springfield offers a nice set of accessories with the gun, making for a great value in the price.

Because Springfield owns the oldest trademarked name for a gun maker in the United States, many will mistakenly claim the gun is American made. Actually, this pistol is manufactured in Croatia by a different company and licensed to Springfield. This is another gun not legal for sale in California and Massachusetts.

3. Sig Sauer P226

This is considered the iconic handgun offered by Sig Sauer and is the gun that built their reputation as a maker of reliable and high quality 9mm guns. The P226 is a favorite of law enforcement and military (including the U.S. Navy Seals), considered easy to acquire a target with and as durable as it gets.

It is very well balanced and is known for reliable operation. All of this comes at a price premium, as much as three times what other guns in this review will cost. A custom version can double even that price.

The P226 is a full-sized duty weapon and is not offered in a compact version. In the Sig Sauer lineup, that place is filled by the P290. Sig offers 25 models of the P226, and with its standard rail system, a seemingly unlimited amount of accessories are available. This gun has multiple safeties, and the hammer when decocked is not in contact with the firing pin. No one can go wrong with the choice of the P226, which is the original standard for a 9mm handgun against which any other must be measured.

4. Glock 17

Glock is the absolute standard for reliability when it comes to a handgun. No other weapon has the reputation for proven operation that the Glock enjoys. These guns will fire every time regardless of the power or quality of the ammunition. The words “Glock Perfection” used in their marketing are derived from perfect performances in reliability trials by military and law enforcement organizations worldwide.

The Glock 17 is the gun that started everything for Glock and astounded the shooting scene, when the Austrian government awarded the contract for their military sidearm to a maker that had never produced a gun before. Owners of Glocks, regardless of model, are among the most loyal that can be found.

The only real disadvantages to the design seem to be in personal preferences concerning the grip feel and the pointing geometry. No one anywhere disputes the reliability, but lots of people think they are ugly and don’t like how they feel. The Springfield XD is a good alternative for these shooters. The Glock has proven to be accurate and well made. It offers excellent value for the midrange price.

5. Beretta 92FS

If there is any one gun that can compete with the Glock and Sig Sauer P226 for the standard measure of what a 9mm should be, it would have to be the Beretta 92FS. This gun replaced the revered Colt M1911 Browning as the standard sidearm for the United States Army. The 92FS has fired as many as 168,000 rounds without a malfunction in reliability trials. The Glock didn’t participate in these trials, so in the shooting community one popular debate is whether the Glock or the Beretta is the most reliable gun. Any buyer of either weapon can rest assured as to the proven exceptional reliability of either gun.

This completely metal handgun is only available as a full size duty weapon available in six models. Heft, size, weight and feel are very similar to the Colt 1911. Field stripping is simple and these guns wear very well. Shooters who own this gun praise its accuracy and its ability to acquire a target when pointing instinctively. Pricing is midway between the Springfield XD and the Sig Sauer P226. That price should be considered an excellent value given this gun’s strong record of military service.

Any of these guns can offer a strong argument to be considered the best 9mm handgun available, with the Glock, P226 and 92FS having the edge in historical data on service usage and reliability.

Tips for Choosing the Best 9mm Handgun

Before you purchase any gun, you need to be familiar with the handgun laws of your state governing who can own, possess, carry (in plain view) and carry (concealed) firearms. Ignorance of the law is no excuse when you go to court, and most states do not honor permits issued in other jurisdictions. Additionally, no one should own or carry a firearm until they have been trained in its use, proper maintenance, and safe storage. The best solution is to take a state certified firearms training class before you purchase your gun.

Because there are so many makes, models, and calibers of firearms available, in all price ranges, it is necessary to define what is meant by the term “best”. The best gun is one which fits comfortably in your hand and is suitable for your needs. Below are some handgun uses you might consider:

Reason to for choosing the best handgun

1. Target practice handgun. If your primary person for buying a gun is to become proficient at hitting a target, the weapon of choice would be a .22 caliber pistol with a six or eight inch barrel. The .22 is the smallest caliber of ammunition in common usage, and thus the most affordable if you are going to be firing a lot of rounds. Generally speaking, the longer the barrel, the greater the accuracy. For beginners, .22s have less recoil and are easier to learn to use.

2. Home defense handgun. Practically any pistol will fit the bill. The purpose is to hopefully frighten an intruder without having to shoot. If you have to shoot, experts concur that a larger caliber weapon using hollow point ammunition is the best way to stop an intruder, so a 9 mm or .45 caliber pistol would be a good choice.

3. Concealed weapon handgun. The purpose of carrying a concealed weapon is self defense. Smaller weapons are obviously easier to conceal, and a shorter barrel is harder for an attacker to grab. Over 75 percent of the time, just brandishing a gun will fend off an attacker, but if you must shoot you want the maximum number of rounds with reasonable stopping power. A .380 or 9 mm automatic with a 2 inch barrel would be the best handgun for this purpose.

4. All purpose weapon. When selecting the best handgun for all uses, you must realize that anything that is all purpose, will be less than optimal for a specific use. A reasonably concealable handgun with excellent stopping power but more affordable ammunition would be a 9mm automatic with a 4 inch barrel.

5. Investment. Gun prices usually just go up. What you might want today will cost more next year. Collectible pistols will go up the most, as an investment.

Larry Pomykalski is an NRA certified pistol instructor and a member of the American Society of Law Enforcement Trainers, as well as a former police officer, former military firearms instructor and lifelong student of the martial arts. He also felt that he had something of value to share with the firearms community, and wondered which gunzines he should approach with the above essay. The problem was that he was dealing in ideas and concepts, and virtually all of the present gunzines only want articles about products and services so that their advertising department can sell space and everyone can make money. This is the American way. This is his first published work.

We will be happy to hear your thoughts

Leave a reply